Shia sunni dialogue imam khomeini views on aisha r. I context is not indicative of supporter, or the like, ii context does not outweigh the proofs. If shiism is the true path, then why arent there more shias then sunnis, or at least why dont there. Prepared by emily hawley, research associate after the death of the prophet mohammad in 632 ce, the muslim community diverged over how to select the next leader of the islamic community they had formed on. Establish a commission of equal citizenship, under the national dialogue center. Why is there so little institutionalized shiasunni dialogue occurring when the need for such dialogue is evident. Exposing the lies about fasting on the day of ashura. The theological, doctrinal and jurisprudential differences between the two main branches of islam has translated into two different visions on the role of the clerics, the ulema. The true path as practised by prophet muhammed saw and his purified family as category. A shiisunni dialogue also known as the right path by sayyid abd alhusayn sharaf aldin almusawi translated from the arabic by yasin t. A shiisunni dialogue also known as the right path a series of letters debating shii and sunni beliefs between the late shii scholar sharaf aldin, and the late sunni scholar and head of alazhar university.
Al murajaat a shii sunni dialogue al murajaat a shii. Full text of english books questioning shia beliefs. Pdf despite a growth in fatalities resulting from organized violence with shia sunni dimensions over the last two decades, in this study, we show. Qatilehussain kon they sunni ya shia internet archive.
Thomas mcelwain pdf alternate pdf shiism imamate and wilayat by s. The leader of the iranian revolution, imam khomeini writes in his book. The sunni and shiite sects of islam encompass a wide spectrum of doctrine, opinion and schools of thought. This leads seamlessly to the second reason why this notion has so much power and influence in the american discourse about the middle east. The war for islam amid a roiling middle east, iran and saudi arabia are fanning the fires of sectarianism and playing politics in a zerosum proxy war of religious fervor. Jesse hirsh host of 3d dialogue speaks with both imam hamid slimi from the international muslims organization and imam syed muhammad rizvi from the jaffari islamic centre about the differences. Author of over thirty books, the vast bulk of his works were. Nor is it a battle between shia and sunni rulers baath regime. The first major eruption of the present sunnishia conflict was during the civil war in iraq 200607, but it is in syria where the latest and likely bloodiest episode of the conflict is now. On the 3rd of october 20, a plenary session on sunnishia dialogue was held as part of the rhodes forum on the island of rhodes, greece. This verse, if one were to scrutinize it, overlooking the verses which precede it and which prohibit taking the infidels for walis, does not connote praising the commander of the faithful or recommending him for leadership and imamate by. Shiasunni dialogue occurring when the need for such dialogue is. Modern sunnishia tensions council on foreign relations.
Shiasunni conflict in yemen involves the shia insurgency in northern yemen. A shiisunni dialogue also known as the right path sayyid abd alhusayn sharaf aldin almusawi. Pdf despite a growth in fatalities resulting from organized violence with shiasunni dimensions over the last two decades, in this study, we show. Dialogue between a sunni and a shia abdullah and abdul hussain sunni. Saudi sunnis expect their leaders to defend the honor and position of the sunni majority, lest shiite victories. Wahhabism, the leading stream of islam in sunni saudi arabia, is extremely antishiite. His own tongue is indeed much more eloquent and outspoken than mine. In the midst of the arab awakening, there is a new sunnishia divide which has greatly complicated the diplomatic and geopolitical challenges facing the united states. These one hundred questions are from the pen of allamah abdul kareem mushtaq, a name that needs no introduction for urdu readers. There were 9 speakers ali alawi, aly elsamman, asma afsaruddin. The split between the two main branches of islam is nearly 1,400 years old, and started with a fight over who should lead the faithful after the prophet muhammads death in 632. But the difference is vast, i believe around 80% sunni to 20% shia. Indeed the model of islamic government was shown by the righteous caliphs kholafaeraashedeen and one that was. Associate professor of history at creighton university in omaha, nebraska.
Mishkatul anwar the lamp niche for the best traditions. Shaikh shaltoot was the head of the renowned alazhar theological school in egypt, one of. Dialogue between a sunni and a shia scholars of haq. Sunni islam members research service page 2 of 11 the spread of sunni islam today sunnis make up about 8790% of the worlds estimated 1. Sunni response mohammed pbuh failed but imam khomeini succeeded. Irans islamic revolution, which brought shias to power in 1979, and the sunni backlash have fueled a competition for regional dominance. Shia usoolaldeen which path should you follow did allah tell muslims follow the quran and sunnah or the quran and ahlulbayt the practise of shia islam from sunni books the shia perspective on historical events. While infact these four schools of thought are different in nature.
Whereas, the quran mandates muslim unity in the verse. And hold fast, all together, by the rope of god, and be not divided among yourselves. The origins of the sunnishia split in islam by hussein abdulwaheed amin, editor of introduction the shia shahadah declaration of faith states. Shiasunni violence has been on the rise in the last few years, particularly in iraq and pakistan. The mutazillah slowly disappeared, like so many other islamic sects now unknown to the common muslim, and after their disappearance the hanafis, maalikis, shafiis, hanbalis, all started calling themselves sunni, or the followers of the sunnah or way of the holy prophet pbuh. I am born shia but want to know more about sunni islam. I have been thinking about it but i never really understood that it has never happened in the history of islam that a divine figures successor to be appointed by a human. It is true that there are minor variations in the way they take their respective religious heads and attribute meaning to the history of the family of muhammads, however, cultural and political differences hold the most divisive power over the religious forces. Sunnishiaunity enhancing understanding amongst muslims. Shia sunni dialogue by answeringansar shii beliefs in the bible by dr. Shia sunni discussion new pdf documents are added on daily basis. On the 3rd of october 20, a plenary session on sunni shia dialogue was held as part of the rhodes forum on the island of rhodes, greece. Imamate and khalifa from sunni and shia perspectives.
Full text of a calm dialogue between sunnah and shia. Why the myth of sunnishia conflict defines middle east. A former sunni scholar that converted to shia islam in the late 1960. Another shia sunni dialogue shias allegation imam khomeini was the great hero of islam who saved it from the trouble makers. Historical context to modern conflict download fact sheet after the death of the prophet mohammad in 632 ce, the muslim community diverged over how to select the next leader of the islamic community they had formed on the arabian peninsula. Dialogue between two friends, shia and sunni mansab. Islamic library shia islamic pdfs now in collaboration. And remember with gratitude gods favor on you when you were enemies, and he united your hearts so by.
It gives us great pleasure to introduce to you a new pdf publication by shaykh dr. A series of letters debating shii and sunni beliefs between the late shii scholar sharaf aldin, and the late sunni scholar and head of. Abootalebi informed comment the sunnishia schism provides for different narrative and prescriptions for arriving at the utopian islamic society and the incoming of the messiah, almahdi. It was printed at al irfan press, saida lebanon, in 55 a. What is missing in our sunnishia conflict narrative. Shiite populations constitute a majority in iran, iraq, bahrain, and azerbaijan. Organisation of islamic cooperations secretarygeneral tells ahram online that rapprochement between different muslim sects is essential. The word shia applies today to a group who are independent of the sunnis in terms. The sunnishiite schism also provokes violence between muslims in such places as pakistan, nigeria and indonesia. With shiite iran on the cusp of nuclear arms, and with demonstrated victories by irans proxies in iraq, lebanon, and gaza, the saudi rulers cannot afford to be seen coddling local shiites. Shia muslims view the book as being one of the best known books in islamic studies due to. Solving the sunnishia conflict begins with tehran the.
What students need to know by john calvert april 2010 vol. Lately ive seen a lot of sunni shia divide, and during a dangerous time for muslims, i think it really has to stop. Call for papers, the shia institute annual symposium 2016. This pdf book was published with permission of author. Shia islam, shia sunni dialogue, shia sunni dialogue pdf documents, uncategorized. This is the famous fatwa religious verdict of one of the sunni worlds most revered scholars, shaikh mahmood shaltoot with regard to the shia. Every month, it seems, scores of shias and sunnis are killed in a vicious titfortat between extremists on both sides. This essay is excerpted from his book divisions within islam, part of a 10volume. With islamic state out of the picture, the people of iraq are breathing a sigh of relief. There were 9 speakers ali alawi, aly elsamman, asma afsaruddin, ghomali khoshroo, mohd faisal musa, nader elbizri, seyyed javad miri meynagh, syed. Why is there such huge difference between the number of followers of the two sects.
According to such thinking, the primary function of the prophet was kingship, and, therefore, anyone holding the reins of power was the. Full text of english books questioning shia beliefs see other formats. The story, as told, usually goes something like this. The difference between sunni and shia sects of islam are not to the gigantic proportions as most western literature assume. We hope this benefits the ummah and helps them to clarify some issues for them. The majority of the worlds muslim population follows the sunni branch of islam, and approximately 1015% of all muslims follow the shiite shiite, shia, shia branch. A shiisunni dialogue by sayyid abd alhussain sharaf aldin almusawi 3 translated from the arabic by yasin t. A series of letters debating shii and sunni beliefs between the late shii scholar sharaf aldin, and the late sunni. Shia islam, shiasunni dialogue, shiasunni dialogue pdf documents. O sons of ali and husain and sons of abu bakr and umar, this is not a fight between shias and sunnis.
559 1031 186 70 1293 1554 169 1263 1340 244 678 1625 55 793 192 139 1101 768 760 1502 1432 1097 1260 1352 653 1157 49 574 640 1039 473 953